Yolanda McClary (Herself - Crime Scene Investigator), Kelly Siegler (Herself - Prosecutor), Steve Barnhart (Himself - Vigo County Sheriff's Office), James Corah (Himself - Earl's Former Manager), Bonnie Dean (Herself - Kathy's Sister), Maxine Dean (Herself - Kathy's Mother), Gregory T. Ewing (Himself - Vigo County Sheriff's Office), Derek Fell (Himself - Vigo County Sheriff's Office), Roland Kohr (Himself - Former Coroner Vigo County), John Moats (Himself - Vigo County Sheriff's Office)