Carrie Preston (Elsbeth Tascioni), Carra Patterson (Officer Kaya Blanke), Wendell Pierce (Captain C.W. Wagner), Daniel K. Isaac (Lt. Steve Connor), Nathan Lane (Phillip Cross), Kiaya Scott (Michelle), Michael Muñiz (Opera patron), Daniel Oreskes (Detective Buzz Fleming), Christian Borle (Carter Schmidt), Daniel Davis (Dr. Yablonski)