Jake Johnson (Ryan O'Malley), Damon Wayans jr. (Justin Miller), Rob Riggle (Patrol Officer Segars), Nina Dobrev (Josie), James D'Arcy (Mossi Kasic), Keegan Michael Key (Pupa), Andy García (Detective Brolin), Jonathan Lajoie (Todd Connors), Tom Mardirosian (Georgie), Natasha Leggero (Annie), Rebecca Koon (), Joshua Ormond (), L. Warren Young (), Nelson Bonilla (), Brian Oerly (), Jeff Chase (), Alec Rayme (), Randall P. Havens (), Chas Harvey (), Dane Davenport (), Raven-Danielle Baker (), Chelsea Hayes (), Kara Michele Wilder (), Briana Venskus (), Jwaundace Candece (), Sam Medina (), Americus Abesamis (), Wilson Schwarz (), Andrew Kochman (), Hoke Faser (), Ron Caldwell (), Ted Huckabee (), Jackie Costello (), Joy Glover Walters (), Daniel Parvis (), Justin Miles (), Michael Scialabba (), Matt Mangum (), Desmond Phillips (), Corey James Wright ()