Winona Ryder (Evelyn Finkel), Anthony Boyle (Alvin Levin), Zoe Kazan (Elizabeth 'Bess' Levin), Morgan Spector (Herman Levin), David Krumholtz (Monty Levin), John Turturro (Rabbi Lionel Bengelsdorf), Azhy Robertson (Phillip Levin), Lee Tergesen (Agent Don McCorkle), Jacob Laval (Seldon Wishnow), Michael Kostroff (Shepsie Tirchwell)